Monday, November 2, 2026Mon, Nov 2 DirectoryBecome a memberSubscribe

Westchester Made

Business News and Reviews

News

Fulgenzi Responds To Critiques Over Clay Bird Lane Controversy

Mount Pleasant Town Supervisor Carl Fulgenzi responds to critiques from former councilman Mark Saracino, as resident fears grip election season. The controversy surrounds the Clay Bird Lane organic recycling center.

Original reporting · theexaminernews.com

Original: “Fulgenzi Responds to Saracino’s Clay Bird Critiques as Resident Fears Grip Election Season”

Read “Fulgenzi Responds to Saracino’s Clay Bird Critiques as Resident Fears Grip Election Season” at The Examiner News →
Fulgenzi Responds to Saracino’s Clay Bird Critiques as Resident Fears Grip Election Season
Image: The Examiner News

How this was written. Westchester Made wrote this article with a language model from The Examiner News’s reporting (model: @cf/meta/llama-3.3-70b-instruct-fp8-fast); it describes that reporting rather than adding to it. The original, linked above, is the full story.

Key points from The Examiner News’s report

  • Mount Pleasant Town Supervisor Carl Fulgenzi has responded to critiques from former councilman Mark Saracino over the Clay Bird Lane controversy.
  • The controversy surrounds the town's handling of an organic recycling center that has been the subject of resident complaints for years.
  • The town has approved $391,595 in bids for contracts to begin cleaning up the site, but Saracino has raised concerns about the visibility of these contracts.
  • The issue has become a key factor in the upcoming town election, with Fulgenzi facing a challenge from Democrat Tom Abinanti.
  • The dispute has led to litigation, with the town seeking to recover costs associated with removing material from the site.

The debate over Clay Bird Lane has spilled into public view, with former Mount Pleasant Councilman Mark Saracino accusing town officials of a 'profound and shameful lack of integrity' in their governance of the town, according to The Examiner News. Saracino resigned from the board in June and has since issued blistering attacks on the current administration.

Saracino's criticisms center on the town's handling of the Clay Bird Lane controversy, which involves an organic recycling center that has been the subject of resident complaints for years. The town has approved $391,595 in bids for contracts to begin cleaning up the site, but Saracino has raised concerns about the visibility of these contracts.

Fulgenzi has acknowledged the lack of a formal contract with the facility's operator, Amodio's Garden Center, but rejected Saracino's larger claims. He characterized Saracino as a quitter who could have worked with the town to resolve issues if he had stayed on the board. The supervisor also defended the town's assertion that residents had not been put in harm's way, despite fires occurring at the site.

The controversy has become a key issue in the upcoming town election, with Fulgenzi facing a challenge from Democrat Tom Abinanti. Abinanti has stated that the Clay Bird Lane fiasco is an example of Fulgenzi's mismanagement, which is damaging the environment and wasting taxpayer dollars. The election is set to take place on Tuesday, with Fulgenzi seeking another term as supervisor.

The Clay Bird Lane facility has been in operation for roughly half a century, and Fulgenzi has noted that the town has a police practice range nearby. However, resident Deborah Gargiulo has raised concerns about the health impacts of the facility and is prepared for a long fight over the issue. The town has sought to recover costs associated with removing material from the site, and the dispute has led to litigation.

Fulgenzi has described the arrangement with Amodio's Garden Center as a good-faith agreement, where the company processed town-owned materials and was permitted to sell the resulting mulch. However, problems arose when the town discovered that the company had brought in materials from outside Mount Pleasant without authorization. The supervisor has said that the town acted as soon as it got this information and clarified the situation.

The controversy has highlighted tensions between Fulgenzi and Saracino, who were once allies. Saracino has voiced support for Democrat Anna Nelson, who is running for the Town Board seat he vacated. Fulgenzi has characterized Saracino as an alarmist who expected local government to move faster than it realistically can. The dispute is likely to continue in the coming days, as the town election approaches.

Questions and answers

What is the Clay Bird Lane controversy?

The Clay Bird Lane controversy surrounds the town's handling of an organic recycling center that has been the subject of resident complaints for years.

Who is involved in the controversy?

The controversy involves Mount Pleasant Town Supervisor Carl Fulgenzi, former councilman Mark Saracino, and Democrat Tom Abinanti, who is challenging Fulgenzi in the upcoming town election.

What are the implications of the controversy?

The controversy has highlighted tensions between Fulgenzi and Saracino and has become a key issue in the upcoming town election, with implications for the town's governance and environment.

Read the full story at The Examiner News More from Sunday, November 1, 2026’s edition